What Are the Odds of Winning a Personal Injury Case?

If you’ve been injured due to someone else’s negligence, it’s natural to ask: “What are my chances of winning a personal injury case?” While no lawyer can guarantee an outcome, the odds of success in personal injury cases are often favorable—especially when strong evidence and experienced legal representation are involved.

At Redmond Lawfirm, we help clients understand what affects their chances and how to position their case for the best possible result.

Are Personal Injury Cases Usually Successful?

Yes—many personal injury cases result in compensation for the injured party. The majority of claims are resolved through settlements rather than trials, and plaintiffs often recover damages when liability is clear and injuries are well-documented.

However, outcomes vary based on the facts of each case.

Key Factors That Affect Your Chances of Winning

Several important factors influence the odds of success in a personal injury case:

1. Clear Liability

Cases where fault is clearly established—such as rear-end car accidents—have higher success rates. Disputed or shared fault can reduce compensation.

2. Strong Evidence

Medical records, accident reports, photos, witness statements, and expert testimony all strengthen a case. The more evidence available, the better your chances.

3. Severity and Documentation of Injuries

Well-documented injuries supported by medical treatment significantly improve your likelihood of recovery. Gaps in treatment or delayed care can weaken a claim.

4. Insurance Coverage

The amount of available insurance coverage may affect how much compensation you can recover, even if your case is strong.

5. Legal Representation

Statistically, injury victims represented by attorneys recover more compensation than those who handle claims alone. An experienced lawyer knows how to counter insurance tactics and build a compelling case.

Settlement vs. Trial: Does It Matter?

Most personal injury cases settle before going to trial. Settlements offer:

Faster resolution
Lower legal costs
Reduced stress

If a fair settlement isn’t offered, going to trial may increase compensation—but it also involves more time and uncertainty. A skilled attorney helps determine the best path forward.

Common Mistakes That Hurt Your Chances

Certain actions can reduce your odds of winning, including:

Delaying medical treatment
Giving recorded statements to insurers without legal advice
Accepting early, low settlement offers
Missing legal deadlines
Posting accident details on social media

Having a lawyer early helps you avoid these pitfalls.

How a Personal Injury Lawyer Improves Your Odds

A personal injury lawyer plays a critical role by:

Investigating and preserving evidence
Accurately valuing your claim
Negotiating aggressively with insurance companies
Handling legal filings and deadlines
Representing you in court if necessary

At Redmond Lawfirm, we focus on building strong cases that maximize our clients’ chances of success.

Why Choose Redmond Lawfirm?

Clients trust Redmond Lawfirm because we provide:

Honest case evaluations
Clear communication and realistic expectations
No upfront fees—you pay nothing unless we win
Dedicated personal injury advocacy

We don’t promise results—we work tirelessly to earn them.

Areas We Serve

BRONX

BROOKLYN

MANHATTAN

QUEENS

Client Testimonials

We Treat Our Clients Like Family

I count myself as a very lucky person to have come across their number in Google. I was so desperately looking for a personal injury law firm to take my case and represent me. Neil did not hesitate, after a few minutes on hold, he checked out my case and told me he would be able to help. I breathed out a sigh of relief because I was between a rock and a hard place. I feel like I'm in good hands, I feel safe and at ease because I'm being represented by competent people who care.

Rose Marie Fernandez

My first impression of the Redmond Law firm is that they are reliable and they are very objective about the cases that they take. They take the time necessary to do their research and they value every client. They treat their clients with respect. They strive for ultimate results and they take all their cases seriously. I had the pleasure of meeting my paralegal Yaki and she made me feel comfortable and at ease. Speaking with Neil is like speaking with a friend. His vibes are positive and he is very understanding I would recommend this firm to my family and friends or to anyone who is looking for individualized attention and who doesn't want to feel like another number. As a small firm this is one of its many advantages.

Annette Bent

I had eye surgery to remove a cataract which resulted in malpractice performed by a Doctor. After difficulty obtaining a Lawyer. I was recommended to Redmond Law firm. They immediately called me into their office. Their staff was highly professional and sensitive to my concerns. They asked relevant questions concerning my case and provided me with good instructions. When I left the office i felt relieved and confident that I made the right decision in using Redmond Law firm. Redmond Law firm gets my high praises and I would definitely recommend them.

Jamal Rashid

Redmond Law Firm is awesome dude. They really go out their way to make sure your needs are met, no matter your circumstances or situation, the Redmond Law Firm are awesome professionally when it comes to handling your litigation, truth be told they will put the icing on the cake for you.

Perry Burnett

Hi my nickname is Octavia. I'm writing this review as one of plenty of clients that I'm aware Redmond the lawyer and everyone at the law firm I know works quit hard at this law firm not only have I experience the good work of this law firm I am a client that has been treated so well that I honestly have no complaints. They get the job done! They are a great law firm! I recommend them to anyone even friends or family! Wonderful law firm you will be pleased just as I! Please check this law firm out. Have a blessed one

Tay Body

I highly recommend Redmond Law Firm to family, friends as well as coworkers. This firm comes with great staff members that provides wonderful customer service. They are attentive are very informative. So if you’re looking for a Firm that will take affirmative action with great satisfaction. I strongly suggest REDMOND LAW FIRM.

Jermaine Rich

The Redmond Law Firm is an outstanding law Firm. I had the privilege to be on a Jury trial Aprox. 7 Years ago as a Juror in the County of Queens on a Civil case/ matter. I saw how Mr.Redmond was skilled ,knowledgeable and most of all professional, gifted. I said to myself Redmond Esq. is a force to be reckon with. I said to myself if I was ever to get in an accident ( God forbid) I will use Mr. Remond Law firm. I had the privilege to refer someone recently. This law firm has Great Staff shoutout to my Legal Assistant, Rain.

Isaiah Pride

This firm is very professional, someone is always available to take your calls with quick and effective follow ups. The staff is very friendly and helpful, they spend time to make sure every aspect of the case is address.I always feel very satisfied after a conversation about my case. Very good law firm.

Maxie Campbell