Car accidents in New York City happen every day, from busy Manhattan streets to Brooklyn intersections. If you’ve been injured, you might ask:
“How hard is it to win a car accident lawsuit?”
While no case is guaranteed, hiring an experienced car accident lawyer dramatically increases your chances of success. Here’s what NYC drivers need to know.
Factors That Affect Winning a Car Accident Lawsuit

1. Liability Must Be Clear
To win, you must show that the other party was negligent. Evidence includes:
- Police reports
- Eyewitness statements
- Dashcam or surveillance footage
- Accident reconstruction reports
Trusted reference:
- NHTSA – Crash Investigation: https://www.nhtsa.gov/crash
2. Medical Documentation Matters
Courts want proof that your injuries are real, linked to the accident, and documented by medical professionals.
- Mayo Clinic – Car Accident Injury Info: https://www.mayoclinic.org
3. Insurance Company Negotiations
Many cases settle before trial. Insurance companies may:
- Deny claims
- Offer lowball settlements
- Dispute medical expenses
A skilled NYC lawyer helps you negotiate fairly.
- Insurance Information Institute – Auto Claims: https://www.iii.org/article/what-to-do-after-an-auto-accident
4. Statute of Limitations
In New York, you generally have 3 years from the accident to file a personal injury lawsuit. Missing deadlines can make winning impossible.
5. Strength of Evidence
Photographs, medical records, witness testimony, and expert reports all strengthen your case. Without solid evidence, it’s harder to win.
How Hard Is It in NYC Specifically?
New York City presents unique challenges:
- Dense traffic and multiple witnesses with conflicting stories
- Insurance companies are familiar with aggressive NYC defense tactics
- Complex No-Fault insurance rules covering medical costs up to $50,000
- Fast-moving cases where evidence can disappear
With the right attorney, these hurdles become manageable.
How Redmond Law Firm Helps Clients Win

At Redmond Law Firm PLLC, our NYC car accident lawyers:
- Investigate accidents thoroughly, gathering critical evidence
- Handle negotiations with insurance companies aggressively
- Ensure all medical documentation and expert reports are complete
- Prepare the case for trial when necessary
- Fight to maximize compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and pain & suffering
Even if your case seems difficult, an experienced lawyer improves your likelihood of winning significantly.
Tips to Improve Your Chances
- Document Everything – Medical records, photos, witness info
- Follow Medical Advice – Proper treatment helps improve injuries
- Avoid Quick Settlements – Consult an attorney before signing anything
- Hire an Experienced NYC Lawyer – Local expertise matters
Final Thoughts

Winning a car accident lawsuit in NYC isn’t easy, but it’s possible with the right legal guidance. A skilled car accident lawyer increases your chances, ensures your rights are protected, and fights to maximize your compensation.
📞 Call Redmond Law Firm PLLC today for a free consultation and learn how we can help you win your case.